Central Islip, NY Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Shopping Smith Haven Mall $$ 195 reviews Shopping Centers (631) 724-1433 313 Smith Haven MallLake Grove, NY 11755 T J Maxx image/svg+xml $$ 4 reviews Department Stores (631) 348-6778 1820 Veterans HwyIslandia, NY 11749 Westfield South Shore $$ 45 reviews Shopping Centers (631) 665-8600 1701 Sunrise HwyBay Shore, NY 11706 Mayfair Shopping Center $$ 1 reviews Shopping Centers (800) 488-0768 10-2020 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY 11725 Explosive Bargains $ 7 reviews Thrift Stores, Antiques (934) 777-2934 127 Smithtown BlvdSte 18 Blast From The Past $ 13 reviews Toy Stores, Music & DVDs, Video Game Stores (631) 328-1693 125 W Main StBay Shore, NY 11706 Homesense $ 10 reviews Rugs, Furniture Stores, Home Decor (631) 499-1503 4 Henry StCommack, NY 11725 Marshalls $$ 23 reviews Department Stores (631) 751-8820 2200 Nesconset HwyStony Brook, NY 11790 Nordstrom Rack $ 2 reviews Department Stores, Shoe Stores, Women's Clothing (631) 954-3853 854 Sunrise HwyBay Shore, NY 11706 Zimmerman's Home $ 1 reviews Furniture Stores (631) 483-2031 57 Garfield AveEast Islip, NY 11730 On a Whim Gift Boutique $$ 4 reviews Gift Shops (631) 650-6483 63 W Main StEast Islip, NY 11730 Primark $ 2 reviews Accessories, Men's Clothing, Women's Clothing (631) 282-8632 9 Smith Haven MallLake Grove, NY 11755 Pat's Market Place $$ 53 reviews Grocery (631) 446-1616 300 E Main StEast Islip, NY 11730 Remember Yesteryears $$ 42 reviews Antiques, Jewelry, Thrift Stores (631) 654-3052 901 Montauk HwyOakdale, NY 11769 Dress Gala $$ 35 reviews Women's Clothing (631) 486-7737 1143 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY 11725 Wild Fork $ 2 reviews Shopping Centers, Grocery (631) 686-3111 2027 Smith Haven PlazaLake Grove, NY 11755 Hobby Lobby $ 15 reviews Art Supplies, Hobby Shops (631) 665-2604 2060 Sunrise HwyBay Shore, NY 11706